✦ScienexySCIENCE KNOWLEDGE LIBRARY
General science · SCI-FORM-CHE-768

Commutator of Position and Momentum

The position-momentum commutator expresses the fundamental non-commuting relationship between the position operator and the momentum operator along the same Cartesian direction.

\([\hat{x}, \hat{p}_{x}] = \hat{x}\hat{p}_{x} - \hat{p}_{x}\hat{x} = i\hbar\)

What this formula means

Definition

The position-momentum commutator expresses the fundamental non-commuting relationship between the position operator and the momentum operator along the same Cartesian direction.

Interpretation

Applying position and momentum operators in different orders generally produces different results. Their commutator is a constant proportional to the imaginary unit and the reduced Planck constant.

Scientific Significance

This commutation relation is central to quantum mechanics and leads to the position-momentum uncertainty principle.

Special Cases

  • For different Cartesian components, [x̂, p̂ᵧ] = 0 and [x̂, p̂_z] = 0.

  • The canonical relation in three dimensions is [x̂ᵢ, p̂ⱼ] = iℏδᵢⱼ.

  • The commutator of an operator with itself is zero.

Scientific principle

Principle

In the position representation, the momentum operator is −iℏ times differentiation with respect to position.

Derivation

  • Define the position operator by x̂ψ(x) = xψ(x).

  • Define the momentum operator by p̂ₓψ(x) = −iℏ dψ/dx.

  • Apply x̂p̂ₓ to a test wavefunction: x̂p̂ₓψ = −iℏx(dψ/dx).

  • Apply p̂ₓx̂ using the product rule: p̂ₓx̂ψ = −iℏ[d(xψ)/dx].

  • Expand the derivative: p̂ₓx̂ψ = −iℏ[ψ + x(dψ/dx)].

  • Subtract the two expressions: [x̂,p̂ₓ]ψ = iℏψ.

  • Therefore, [x̂,p̂ₓ] = iℏ.

Final Result

[x̂,p̂ₓ] = iℏ

Variables and their meanings

X̂

Position operator along the x-axis.

P̂ₓ

Momentum operator along the x-axis.

I

Imaginary unit, satisfying i² = −1.

ℏ

Reduced Planck constant.

Δᵢⱼ

Kronecker delta, equal to 1 when i = j and 0 otherwise.

Ψ(x)

A sufficiently differentiable test wavefunction in the relevant operator domain.

SI units and conversions

SIUnit

kg·m²/s for the commutator product.

Dimensional Formula

[M L² T⁻¹]

Explanation

Position multiplied by momentum has units m × kg·m/s = kg·m²/s, the same as ℏ.

Useful Conversion

ℏ ≈ 1.054571817 × 10⁻³⁴ J·s.

Conditions of use

  • The operators must act on suitable wavefunctions in their common domain.

  • The momentum operator in position representation is −iℏ∂/∂x.

  • The canonical commutation relation applies to standard Cartesian position and momentum operators.

  • Boundary conditions must be compatible with the operator definitions.

Limitations and assumptions

  • The simple canonical relation assumes ordinary Cartesian coordinates and standard non-relativistic quantum mechanics.

  • Other coordinate systems can involve more complicated operator expressions.

  • The commutator is an operator identity on an appropriate domain, not an ordinary numerical multiplication rule.

  • Boundary conditions and operator domains can require special treatment in confined systems.

Step-by-step worked examples

ProblemGivenSolutionAnswer

Calculate the position-momentum commutator for the standard one-dimensional quantum operators.

X̂

Multiplication by x

P̂ₓ

−iℏ d/dx

  • Apply the operators to an arbitrary differentiable function ψ(x).

  • Calculate x̂p̂ₓψ = −iℏx(dψ/dx).

  • Calculate p̂ₓx̂ψ = −iℏ[ψ + x(dψ/dx)].

  • Subtract: x̂p̂ₓψ − p̂ₓx̂ψ = iℏψ.

  • Since this holds for suitable ψ, the operator commutator is iℏ.

[x̂,p̂ₓ] = iℏ.

Determine the commutator [x̂,p̂ᵧ] for different Cartesian coordinates.

X̂

Position operator along x

P̂ᵧ

Momentum operator along y

  • Use the three-dimensional canonical commutation relation [x̂ᵢ,p̂ⱼ] = iℏδᵢⱼ.

  • Here, i = x and j = y.

  • Because x and y are different coordinates, δₓᵧ = 0.

  • Therefore, [x̂,p̂ᵧ] = iℏ × 0.

  • The commutator equals zero.

[x̂,p̂ᵧ] = 0.

Real-world applications

  • Deriving the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty relation.

  • Developing quantum mechanical operator methods.

  • Solving atomic and molecular Schrödinger equations.

  • Studying quantum states in confined systems.

  • Understanding the mathematical foundations of quantum chemistry.

Formula Meaning

Definition

The position-momentum commutator expresses the fundamental non-commuting relationship between the position operator and the momentum operator along the same Cartesian direction.

Interpretation

Applying position and momentum operators in different orders generally produces different results. Their commutator is a constant proportional to the imaginary unit and the reduced Planck constant.

Scientific Significance

This commutation relation is central to quantum mechanics and leads to the position-momentum uncertainty principle.

Special Cases

  • For different Cartesian components, [x̂, p̂ᵧ] = 0 and [x̂, p̂_z] = 0.

  • The canonical relation in three dimensions is [x̂ᵢ, p̂ⱼ] = iℏδᵢⱼ.

  • The commutator of an operator with itself is zero.

Sources and further reading

No source has been supplied for this item yet. Treat the claim as needing editorial verification.

← Back to Formula Hub · Suggest a correction or source