Under the work-by-system convention, Q is positive when heat enters the system and negative when heat leaves it. Work is positive when the system transfers energy to its surroundings through work and negative when the surroundings do work on the system. The first law for a closed system with negligible macroscopic kinetic and potential energy changes is then ΔU = Q − W_by. If a textbook instead defines work done on the system as positive, the same energy balance becomes ΔU = Q + W_on. These expressions are physically equivalent because W_on = −W_by. Sign errors commonly arise when a formula from one convention is combined with quantities calculated using another convention.
Sign Conventions for Heat and Work
Sign conventions specify whether heat and work entering or leaving a system are assigned positive or negative values. A common engineering convention takes heat entering the system as positive and work done by the system as positive. Other textbooks use work done on the system as positive, so the convention must be identified before applying thermodynamic equations.
Work-by-system convention: ΔU = Q − W_by. Work-on-system convention: ΔU = Q + W_on, where W_on = −W_by.
Explanation
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | Unit |
|---|---|---|
Q | Net heat transferred into the system; positive inward | J |
W_by | Work done by the system; positive outward | J |
W_on | Work done on the system; positive inward | J |
ΔU | Change in internal energy | J |
Example or application
A system loses 100 J of heat and has 40 J of work done on it. Under the work-by-system convention, Q = −100 J and W_by = −40 J, so ΔU = −100 − (−40) = −60 J. The internal energy decreases by 60 J.
Sources and verification
Sources are shown as provided in the project data. Not every source has yet been independently verified. Please report errors or missing citations.
- OpenStax, University Physics Volume 2, First Law of Thermodynamics; Çengel and Boles, Thermodynamics: An Engineering Approach.