✦ScienexySCIENCE KNOWLEDGE LIBRARY
engineering_science_foundation · SCI-ENG-001-008

Engineering Problems and Problem-Solving Methods

Explains how engineers identify, define, analyze and solve technical problems using systematic reasoning, mathematical models, experimental evidence, computational tools and engineering judgment.

Explanation

Engineering problem

An engineering problem is a situation in which an existing system, process or product fails to meet a need or where a new capability is required under specified technical and practical constraints.

Problem types

TypeDescription

Analysis Problem

Determining the behavior or performance of an existing system when its characteristics and operating conditions are known.

Design Problem

Developing a system or solution that satisfies a set of requirements.

Optimization Problem

Selecting the best solution according to a defined objective while satisfying constraints.

Troubleshooting Problem

Identifying the causes of an unexpected behavior, fault or performance failure.

Research Problem

Investigating a technical question for which existing knowledge or models may be incomplete.

Systems Integration Problem

Ensuring that different components and subsystems operate correctly together.

Systematic problem solving method

StepNameDescriptionOutput

1

Recognize the Problem

Identify the gap between the current condition and the desired condition.

A preliminary problem statement.

2

Define the Problem

Describe the problem precisely, including its scope, affected systems, requirements and boundaries.

A clear and measurable problem definition.

3

Gather Information

Collect relevant measurements, specifications, technical documentation, operating data and scientific information.

A reliable evidence base.

4

Identify Constraints

Determine technical, financial, safety, environmental, legal and time limitations.

A list of constraints and acceptance criteria.

5

Develop Possible Solutions

Generate alternative approaches using scientific reasoning, design methods and relevant experience.

A set of candidate solutions.

6

Model and Analyze

Use mathematical equations, physical models, simulation or experiments to predict the behavior of candidate solutions.

Predicted performance and technical evidence.

7

Evaluate Alternatives

Compare solutions according to performance, safety, cost, reliability, sustainability and feasibility.

A justified preferred solution.

8

Implement the Solution

Develop, construct, configure or modify the selected system using appropriate procedures.

An implemented engineering solution.

9

Test and Verify

Measure performance and determine whether the solution satisfies the defined requirements.

Test results and verification evidence.

10

Review and Improve

Analyze results, correct weaknesses, document decisions and identify future improvements.

A validated and documented solution or an improved design.

Problem solving tools

ToolPurpose

Root Cause Analysis

Identify the underlying causes of a problem rather than only addressing its visible symptoms.

Five Whys

Explore a chain of possible causes by repeatedly asking why an issue occurred.

Fishbone Diagram

Organize potential causes into categories for systematic investigation.

Pareto Analysis

Prioritize significant causes or problems based on their measured contribution.

Failure Mode and Effects Analysis

Identify potential failure modes, their effects and suitable risk-reduction actions.

Decision Matrix

Compare candidate solutions against weighted evaluation criteria.

Simulation

Study system behavior under selected conditions without immediately constructing a complete physical system.

Experimental Testing

Collect physical evidence to evaluate predictions and verify performance.

Engineering problem characteristics

  • Problems may have incomplete or uncertain information.

  • Several solutions may be technically acceptable.

  • Different requirements may conflict.

  • A solution may need to balance cost, performance, safety and environmental impact.

  • The final result must be justified using evidence and engineering judgment.

Verification and validation

Verification

Checks whether the solution conforms to specified requirements and design specifications.

Validation

Checks whether the solution actually satisfies the intended need in its intended context.

Distinction

A system may meet its written specifications but still fail to address the user's real problem.

Example or application

Scenario

Investigating why a water-pumping system delivers less water than expected.

Step by step investigation

StepActionExplanation

1

Define the problem.

Compare the measured flow rate with the required flow rate.

2

Collect operating data.

Record available pump specifications, operating conditions, flow measurements and pressure readings.

3

Identify possible causes.

Consider pipe losses, incorrect operating conditions, restrictions, air entry or equipment deterioration.

4

Develop testable hypotheses.

For example, determine whether excessive pressure loss is contributing to the low flow rate.

5

Analyze and test.

Compare measured pressure and flow conditions with appropriate system calculations and equipment specifications.

6

Evaluate corrective options.

Compare maintenance, component replacement or system redesign according to technical suitability and cost.

7

Verify the result.

Repeat the relevant measurements and determine whether the required flow performance has been achieved.

Learning point

A systematic investigation avoids replacing equipment based only on assumptions and instead uses evidence to identify the underlying cause.

Definition

Engineering problem-solving is a systematic process of defining technical needs, analyzing evidence, developing and evaluating alternatives, implementing solutions and verifying their performance.

Purpose

  • Develop a repeatable approach to technical problem-solving.

  • Teach learners how to identify and define engineering problems.

  • Introduce analytical, experimental and computational methods.

  • Improve the ability to compare alternatives and justify decisions.

Importance

  • Engineering projects frequently involve incomplete information and competing requirements.

  • Systematic problem-solving reduces errors and unnecessary costs.

  • Root cause analysis helps prevent repeated failures.

  • Testing and verification provide evidence that a solution works as intended.

  • Documented reasoning improves communication and accountability.

Common mistakes

  • Starting calculations before defining the problem.

  • Ignoring important assumptions and operating conditions.

  • Treating symptoms as confirmed root causes.

  • Considering only one possible solution.

  • Selecting a solution without checking safety and feasibility.

  • Failing to test the implemented solution.

  • Ignoring measurement uncertainty and unreliable data.

Related Topics

  • Engineering Analysis

  • Engineering Design

  • Engineering Systems

  • Engineering Innovation

Sources and verification

Sources are shown as provided in the project data. Not every source has yet been independently verified. Please report errors or missing citations.

  • Dym, C. L. et al. Engineering Design: A Project-Based Introduction.
  • ABET Engineering Accreditation Criteria.
  • INCOSE Systems Engineering Handbook.
  • NASA Systems Engineering Handbook.

Suggest a correction or source · More in Engineering Science