Mathematical problems can sometimes be solved exactly using algebraic formulas, symbolic manipulation or analytical techniques. For example, the equation x² − 4 = 0 has exact solutions x = ±2. However, many problems have solutions that cannot be expressed conveniently in elementary mathematical forms. In such cases, numerical methods produce approximate solutions. An approximation is useful when its error is sufficiently small for the intended application. The acceptable accuracy depends on the problem: an approximation suitable for a simple estimate may not be sufficient for a highly sensitive scientific calculation.
Exact Solutions and Approximate Solutions
An exact solution satisfies a mathematical problem precisely, whereas an approximate solution is a numerical value that is sufficiently close to the exact result for a specified purpose.
Eₐ = |x − x*|
Explanation
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
x | Exact solution. |
x* | Approximate solution. |
Eₐ | Absolute error. |
Example or application
The exact value of √2 is irrational and cannot be represented by a finite decimal. The value 1.4142 is an approximate decimal representation.
Definition
An exact solution is a value or expression that satisfies the mathematical problem without approximation. An approximate solution is a computed value that is close to the exact solution within an acceptable error tolerance.
Purpose
To distinguish exact mathematical results from numerical approximations and understand when approximate solutions are necessary.
Importance
This distinction is fundamental to numerical analysis. It helps learners understand why numerical answers must be accompanied by accuracy considerations and why the quality of an approximation depends on its error and intended use.
Learning Objectives
Define exact and approximate solutions.
Distinguish exact expressions from decimal approximations.
Calculate absolute error.
Explain why approximate solutions are useful.
Understand the role of acceptable error tolerance.
Key Concepts
Exact value
Approximate value
Absolute error
Relative error
Error tolerance
Irrational numbers
Numerical solution
Working Principle
An approximate solution is generated by a numerical method and compared with an exact solution when the latter is known. If the exact solution is unknown, residuals, error bounds or other numerical estimates may be used to assess the result.
Process
Identify the mathematical problem.
Determine whether an exact solution is available.
If possible, calculate the exact result.
Apply a numerical method to obtain an approximation.
Measure the difference between the exact and approximate values when possible.
Compare the error with the required tolerance.
Applications
Equation solving
Scientific measurement
Engineering design
Numerical integration
Computer simulations
Approximation of irrational constants
Worked Example
Problem
Find the absolute error when √2 is approximated by 1.4142.
Steps
Use √2 ≈ 1.4142135624.
The approximate value is 1.4142.
Absolute error = |1.4142135624 − 1.4142|.
Absolute error ≈ 0.0000135624.
Answer
The absolute error is approximately 1.35624 × 10⁻⁵.
Common Misconceptions
An approximate solution is not necessarily a wrong solution; it may be the most practical result available.
An exact expression such as √2 can be exact even though its decimal expansion is infinite.
A large number of decimal digits does not automatically prove that a numerical algorithm is accurate.
The acceptable error depends on the application and should not be chosen arbitrarily.
Practice Questions
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
Is √2 an exact value or an approximate value? | It is an exact value. |
Is 1.4142 an exact representation of √2? | No. It is an approximation. |
Find the absolute error when 3.14 is used to approximate π. | Approximately |3.14159265 − 3.14| = 0.00159265. |
Key Takeaway
Exact solutions satisfy mathematical problems precisely, while approximate solutions provide practical numerical values whose accuracy must be evaluated.
Prerequisites
SCI-MAT-014-001
SCI-MAT-014-004
Basic arithmetic
Decimal numbers
Reference
Burden, R. L., Faires, J. D., and Burden, A. M. Numerical Analysis.
Chapra, S. C., and Canale, R. P. Numerical Methods for Engineers.
Related Topics
SCI-MAT-014-006
SCI-MAT-014-011
SCI-MAT-014-012
SCI-MAT-014-020
Sources and verification
Sources are shown as provided in the project data. Not every source has yet been independently verified. Please report errors or missing citations.
- Source verification pending; check an authoritative textbook, university, standards body, or peer-reviewed source.