✦ScienexySCIENCE KNOWLEDGE LIBRARY
learning-resource · SCI-PSY-002-201

Psychology and Human Problem-Solving

Investigates how people identify problems, represent information, generate possible solutions, reason through alternatives, overcome obstacles and evaluate the effectiveness of their solutions.

Explanation

A fuller explanation is being developed. Verify this concept with cited sources before relying on it.

Example or application

A worked example has not yet been added.

Conceptual Coverage

Definition

Problem-solving is a goal-directed cognitive process in which a person identifies a gap between a current state and a desired state and attempts to find a suitable way to reduce that gap.

Major Stages

  • Problem identification: recognizing that a problem exists.

  • Problem representation: understanding the relevant information, constraints and goals.

  • Strategy generation: producing possible approaches.

  • Strategy selection: choosing an appropriate approach.

  • Implementation: carrying out the selected strategy.

  • Evaluation: checking whether the solution works.

  • Revision: modifying the approach when necessary.

Problem Types

  • Well-defined problems have clear goals, constraints and possible solution procedures.

  • Ill-defined problems have incomplete or ambiguous goals and may permit multiple acceptable solutions.

  • Routine problems can often be solved using familiar procedures.

  • Novel problems require new combinations of knowledge or strategies.

  • Individual problems are addressed by one person, while collaborative problems involve multiple participants.

Problem Solving Strategies

  • Algorithms follow systematic procedures that can produce a solution when applicable.

  • Heuristics use simplified strategies to guide problem-solving.

  • Trial and error tests possible approaches and evaluates their outcomes.

  • Analogy applies structural similarities from a previously solved problem.

  • Means-end analysis reduces differences between the current and desired states.

  • Decomposition divides a complex problem into smaller manageable parts.

Scientific Foundation

Major Contributors

  • Gestalt psychologists investigated insight and the organization of problem situations.

  • Karl Duncker studied functional fixedness and problem representation.

  • Allen Newell and Herbert Simon developed influential information-processing approaches to problem-solving.

  • George Pólya contributed systematic methods for mathematical problem-solving.

  • John Sweller developed cognitive load theory, which has influenced research on complex learning and problem-solving.

Research Foundations

Problem-solving research uses controlled experiments, verbal protocols, behavioural observations, computational models, educational studies and performance measures.

Theoretical Approaches

  • Information-processing approaches examine the mental operations involved in solving problems.

  • Gestalt approaches emphasize restructuring and insight.

  • Constructivist approaches examine how prior knowledge influences problem representation.

  • Metacognitive approaches investigate monitoring and regulation of problem-solving.

  • Distributed cognition examines how people use external tools and social resources.

Research Evidence

Performance can be influenced by prior knowledge, problem representation, working memory demands, strategy selection, feedback and the structure of the task.

Deep Understanding

Problem Representation

A problem must be represented accurately before an effective solution can be selected. Misunderstanding the goal or constraints can lead to inappropriate strategies.

Prior Knowledge

Relevant knowledge helps identify patterns and efficient procedures, but inappropriate transfer from previous experiences can create errors.

Functional Fixedness

Functional fixedness occurs when familiar uses of objects or information restrict the ability to consider alternative uses.

Mental Set

A mental set is a tendency to use a familiar strategy even when a different approach may be more effective.

Insight

Insight refers to a sudden change in understanding or problem representation that makes a solution apparent.

Metacognition

Metacognition involves monitoring one's understanding, evaluating progress and changing strategies when needed.

Collaborative Problem Solving

Groups can combine different knowledge and perspectives, but coordination problems and social pressures may also reduce effectiveness.

Mathematical Coverage

Problem Space

A problem space can be represented as a set of possible states and actions that connect the initial state to a goal state.

Search Cost

Formula

Average search cost = Total search effort / Number of explored alternatives

Explanation

This is a simplified descriptive measure; actual cognitive effort may require more detailed operational definitions.

Success Rate

Formula

Problem-solving success rate (%) = (Problems solved successfully / Total problems attempted) × 100

Example

If 16 of 20 problems are solved correctly, the success rate is 80%.

Limitation

Success rate does not capture time, difficulty or solution quality.

Error Reduction

Formula

Error reduction (%) = [(Initial error rate − Final error rate) / Initial error rate] × 100

Example

If an error rate decreases from 20% to 10%, error reduction is 50%.

Limitation

The comparison requires consistent measurement conditions.

Algorithmic Complexity

Computer-based problem-solving may use computational complexity measures such as O(n), O(n²) and O(log n) to describe how resource requirements change with input size. These are computational measures, not direct measures of human cognitive effort.

Practical Learning

Applications

  • Break complex tasks into smaller, clearly defined subproblems.

  • Write down the goal and constraints before choosing a strategy.

  • Generate multiple possible solutions before evaluating them.

  • Use worked examples when learning unfamiliar procedures.

  • Monitor progress and change strategies when evidence indicates that an approach is ineffective.

  • Ask other people to examine assumptions that may have been overlooked.

Worked Example

A learner cannot solve a mathematics problem. Instead of repeatedly applying an unsuccessful method, the learner identifies the known information, clarifies the required result, reviews relevant principles and tests a different strategy.

Learning Activity

Choose a non-sensitive everyday problem. Write its initial state, goal state, constraints, possible actions and evaluation criteria.

Reflection Questions

  • Was the problem represented accurately?

  • Did prior experience help or restrict the solution?

  • How could feedback improve the next attempt?

Critical Thinking

Common Misconceptions

  • Insight is not always independent of previous knowledge or preparation.

  • Trial and error is not necessarily random; it can be systematic.

  • A complicated solution is not automatically better than a simple one.

  • One successful strategy may not work for every problem.

Limitations

  • Laboratory tasks may not reflect the complexity of real-world problems.

  • Verbal reports may not capture every cognitive process.

  • Performance can be affected by motivation, fatigue and familiarity with the task.

  • Group problem-solving may be influenced by unequal participation and conformity.

Critical Questions

  • Has the problem been defined correctly?

  • What assumptions are built into the proposed solution?

  • Are there alternative representations of the problem?

  • How will the quality and consequences of the solution be evaluated?

Knowledge Assessment

Mcqs

QuestionOptionsAnswerExplanation

What is functional fixedness?

  • Difficulty seeing alternative uses for familiar objects

  • The ability to solve every problem quickly

  • Forgetting all previous learning

  • Using an algorithm in every situation

Difficulty seeing alternative uses for familiar objects

Functional fixedness can restrict problem-solving by limiting the perceived possibilities of an object.

Which process involves monitoring and evaluating one's own thinking?

  • Metacognition

  • Classical conditioning

  • Habituation

  • Sensory adaptation

Metacognition

Metacognition supports awareness and regulation of cognitive processes.

Short Questions

  • Describe the major stages of problem-solving.

  • Differentiate between algorithms and heuristics.

  • Explain the role of prior knowledge in problem-solving.

Application Exercise

A group repeatedly fails to complete a project because members disagree about priorities. Identify the problem-solving stages and suggest a structured approach.

Answer Guide

Clarify the shared goal, list constraints, gather relevant information, generate alternatives, establish decision criteria, assign responsibilities and evaluate progress.

Further Learning

Prerequisites

  • Cognitive Psychology

  • Attention and Memory

  • Reasoning and Intelligence

  • Research Methods

Related Concepts

  • Creative Thinking

  • Metacognition

  • Insight

  • Decision-Making

  • Cognitive Load

Interdisciplinary Connections

  • Mathematics studies formal reasoning and structured problem-solving.

  • Computer science investigates algorithms and computational problem-solving.

  • Engineering applies systematic methods to design and technical challenges.

  • Education investigates how problem-solving skills develop through instruction.

Next Topics

  • Psychology in Understanding Social Behaviour

  • Responsible Application of Psychological Knowledge

  • The Relevance of Psychology in Modern Society

Sources and verification

Sources are shown as provided in the project data. Not every source has yet been independently verified. Please report errors or missing citations.

  • Source verification pending; check an authoritative textbook, university, standards body, or peer-reviewed source.

Suggest a correction or source · More in Foundations of Psychology